How to Cook a Steak Like Ruth’s Chris at Home

To cook a steak like Ruth’s Chris at home, season a thick steak with kosher salt and cracked black pepper, reverse-sear it, and finish it with butter in a hot skillet. The oven cooks the center gently; the skillet builds the browned, buttery crust. This home-kitchen method delivers the steakhouse essentials without trying to reproduce a commercial broiler.

What Makes a Ruth’s Chris–Style Steak Different

The appeal is straightforward: flavorful beef, a well-browned exterior, a juicy center, and butter that complements rather than hides the steak. You do not need a complicated marinade or a heavily seasoned compound butter.

Re-create the crust, doneness, and butter finish, not the restaurant’s equipment.

Reverse searing is especially useful for thick cuts, including bone-in ribeye. Cooking gently before searing gives you more control over the center than trying to cook a thick steak entirely over intense heat.

The crust depends on a dry surface and good contact with the pan. Searing creates flavor through browning; it does not seal juices inside the meat. That distinction matters because leaving a steak in the skillet longer will not make it juicier. It will keep cooking the center.

How to Cook Ruth’s Chris–Style Steak at Home

Set out your ingredients and equipment before you begin:

  • A thick ribeye, New York strip, or filet mignon
  • Kosher salt and freshly cracked black pepper
  • Neutral, high-smoke-point oil, such as grapeseed oil
  • Butter, preferably unsalted so you can control the seasoning
  • A rimmed baking sheet, foil, and an oven-safe wire rack
  • A cast-iron skillet, tongs, and a spoon
  • A meat thermometer and a clean resting plate or cutting board

Use a skillet that gives the steak room to lie flat. Crowding several steaks into a small pan makes it harder to maintain the heat needed for browning.

Choose your cut according to the eating experience you want:

Steak Best For What to Look For
Ribeye Rich beef flavor and a buttery texture Marbling distributed through the meat, not just a large outside fat cap
New York strip Beefy flavor with a firmer bite An evenly thick steak that will contact the pan well
Filet mignon A very tender, leaner steak A thick, evenly shaped portion
Bone-in ribeye A substantial steakhouse-style presentation A broad section of meat where you can measure the center without touching bone

Step 1: Dry, Season, and Set the Steak on a Rack

  1. Pat the steak dry with paper towels, including its edges.
  2. Season both sides and the edges evenly with kosher salt and freshly cracked black pepper. Aim for an even coating rather than a thick blanket that obscures the meat.
  3. For the counter-rest stage of Ruth’s Chris’s reverse-sear method, place the steak on a wire rack inside a foil-lined baking sheet and let it stand for 30 minutes to an hour.

The rack allows air to circulate during baking.

Treat the counter wait as a tempering period, not a guarantee that a thick steak’s center will reach room temperature. Do not extend the wait to force that result; in a hot kitchen, skip the counter rest and cook from refrigerated. Keep raw-meat utensils separate from the clean utensils and plate you will use for serving.

Step 2: Bake Gently and Measure the Center

  1. Preheat the oven to 275°F for Ruth’s Chris’s reverse-sear method.
  2. Put the baking sheet, rack, and steak in the oven.
  3. Measure the temperature in the thickest part of the meat, away from bone or a large pocket of fat. With an instant-read thermometer, inserting the probe horizontally from the side can make the center easier to locate.
  4. For the general oven-pull rule in Ruth’s Chris’s reverse-sear method, remove the steak when its center is 5–10°F below your intended final internal temperature.

Choose the final temperature before you start cooking. Choose your target temperature before cooking, then rest the steak before serving.

For medium-rare, follow Ruth’s Chris’s specific oven-pull rule rather than the general 5–10°F offset: remove the steak before its center exceeds 115°F. That is the steak’s internal temperature limit for baking, not the oven setting or serving temperature. It leaves more room for the skillet finish than the method’s general offset, so the two instructions are not interchangeable.

Use the thermometer rather than a fixed baking time. Thickness, bone, starting temperature, and oven performance all affect how quickly the center heats. Once the steak approaches its oven-pull point, have the skillet ready.

Step 3: Heat the Skillet and Add Oil

  1. Heat a cast-iron skillet over medium-high heat, the setting used in Ruth’s Chris’s reverse-sear method. Turn on your kitchen exhaust fan.
  2. Add a couple tablespoons of neutral oil with a high smoke point, such as grapeseed oil.
  3. Swirl the oil across the cooking surface. If the steak has visible surface moisture, gently blot it before transferring it to the skillet.

The oil should flow freely and shimmer. Heavy, billowing smoke means the pan is hotter than necessary; reduce the heat before adding the steak.

Do not start the sear in butter alone. Butter’s milk solids can burn while you are trying to develop the initial crust. Oil handles the first contact with the hot pan; butter comes later for flavor and additional browning.

Step 4: Sear, Flip, and Butter-Baste

  1. Lay the steak into the skillet away from you to reduce splashing. Let it make full contact with the pan rather than moving it around immediately.
  2. Follow the pan finish in Ruth’s Chris’s reverse-sear method: sear the first side for about 1 minute, then flip, add 1 tablespoon of butter, and baste the second side for about 45 seconds.
  3. To baste, carefully tilt the skillet so the melted butter pools, then spoon it over the exposed surface of the steak.

The searing times are starting points for developing the exterior. Burner output, pan temperature, and steak thickness still matter.

Look for a deep brown crust. The butter can foam and turn nutty brown, but it should not become black or smell acrid. Reduce the heat if it darkens too quickly.

Step 5: Check the Temperature, Rest, and Serve

  1. Measure the center again. Remove the steak from the heat when the center reaches your selected endpoint.
  2. If the crust is ready but the center is still below your target, return the steak to its rack in the 275°F oven. Continue checking the center rather than burning the exterior in the skillet.
  3. Transfer the steak to a clean plate or cutting board and rest it for at least 3 minutes. Do not wrap it tightly, which traps steam against the crust.
  4. Spoon the pan butter over the steak before serving. Serve whole or slice across the grain.

Ruth’s Chris serves its steaks on 500°F plates, but that is a restaurant service detail, not a temperature to reproduce with ordinary home dinnerware. Use a comfortably warm serving plate, and do not place a plate in the oven unless it is specifically oven-safe.

A very hot serving surface can continue cooking the steak after it leaves the pan. At home, serving promptly on a warm plate gives you better control.

Have your side dishes ready before the skillet finish. Mashed potatoes and creamed spinach fit the steakhouse style; short-grain rice and sautéed mushrooms also work well with the butter and beef juices. For the closest copycat flavor, keep soy sauce out of the pan finish.

Adjustments for Thin and Bone-In Steaks

Thin Steaks

A thin steak has little room between developing a crust and overcooking its center. It may approach its finishing temperature in the oven before you have enough time left for a useful skillet sear.

For this reverse-sear recipe, buying a thicker cut is the simplest adjustment. If you already have a thin steak, do not assume that the full oven stage and skillet timing will suit it. A thermometer becomes especially important, and the steak may need much less cooking than a thick cut.

Trying to darken an already-cooked steak with a prolonged sear usually trades a better crust for a drier interior.

Bone-In Steaks

A bone-in steak can cook unevenly because its shape and thickness vary. Check the temperature in the main eye of the meat and in another thick area near, but not touching, the bone.

The bone can also hold part of the meat slightly above the skillet. If a patch is not browning, use tongs to adjust the steak’s position so the meat contacts the pan. Do not press hard enough to squeeze the steak or splash hot fat.

Let the meat’s temperature decide when cooking is complete. Bone color and juices around the bone are not reliable doneness tests.

How to Check the Steak and Troubleshoot the Finish

Judge the crust and center separately: browning tells you about the surface, not the center.

Before serving, check that:

  • The exterior is deeply browned.
  • The center has reached your selected endpoint, measured in the thickest part of the meat.
  • The plate is warm without acting as another cooking surface.

If something is off, match the symptom to its likely cause:

Symptom Likely Cause What to Change
Pale, gray exterior A wet surface, crowded skillet, or insufficient pan heat Dry the steak thoroughly and give it room in a properly heated pan
Dark crust but an undercooked center The steak left the oven too early for the intended finish Complete the interior cooking gently in the oven instead of extending the hard sear
Black, bitter butter Butter entered too early or the skillet was excessively hot Begin with oil, add butter after flipping, and lower the heat if it scorches
Overcooked center The oven stage went too far, or searing continued after the crust formed Pull earlier and check the center immediately after searing
Softened crust after resting Tight covering or prolonged contact with pooled liquid Rest without tightly wrapping, then add the buttery finish when serving

If butter burns, do not pour it over the finished steak. Discard the scorched fat and serve the steak without it rather than covering good beef with a bitter sauce.

Once the temperature and crust are right, bring the steak to the table promptly. Slice across the grain if serving it in strips, and spoon the resting juices alongside rather than soaking the entire browned surface.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I Need USDA Prime Beef to Make a Ruth’s Chris–Style Steak?

No. USDA Prime is a useful choice for abundant marbling, but a well-marbled USDA Choice steak can also produce an excellent home result. Look at the individual steak’s marbling, thickness, and shape rather than relying on the grade alone.

Can I Use an Oven Broiler Instead of a Skillet?

Yes, a home broiler can brown steak, but it is not a direct substitute for a commercial steakhouse broiler. Heat output and the steak’s distance from the element vary considerably, so skillet timing cannot simply be transferred to the broiler. For this butter-basted copycat, the oven-and-skillet combination is easier to control.

Do Ruth’s Chris Steaks Come With Sides?

Ruth’s Chris steaks are generally served à la carte, with side dishes ordered separately; combination meals and specials can differ. At home, plan the sides as separate dishes and finish them before the steak’s final sear so everything reaches the table together.